Home

About Us

Practice Areas

Our Team

Service Area

Case Results

Testimonials

Resources

BlogCase StudiesResources

Contact

Back to All Blog Posts

Crossing Guards Hit on Duty in Florida Have Two Claims, Not One

On the morning of August 18, 2026, a 76-year-old school crossing guard was standing in the road outside Grove Park Elementary School in Orange Park, wearing a high-visibility vest and holding a stop sign, doing the job she had done at that intersection for more than twenty years. A vehicle turning from Gano Avenue onto Miller Street struck her. She was taken to the hospital with a brain bleed, a broken back, and broken ribs, underwent two surgeries, and her family has said her recovery is expected to take months. The driver stopped and is cooperating with the investigation. Our firm has no involvement in this matter and no knowledge of it beyond what has been reported. What the reporting does illustrate is a set of Florida rules that almost nobody in that situation knows on the day it happens, starting with the fact that a crossing guard injured on duty is looking at two separate claims rather than one.

The Turning Vehicle Is the Pattern, Not the Exception

The detail worth pausing on is that this was reportedly a turning movement rather than a straight-through collision at speed. That is the single most common way people on foot are struck at intersections, and it happens for reasons that have nothing to do with malice and everything to do with where a driver is looking.

Florida crossing guard and pedestrian struck in a school zone, claims explained

Why Turning Drivers Miss People They Are Looking At

A driver making a turn is typically scanning for a gap in vehicle traffic coming from one direction while steering toward another. Windshield pillars occlude a surprising amount of the field of view, and a pillar can hide an adult-sized object for the entire duration of a slow turn. The driver's attention is on the traffic that could hit them, not on the roadway they are turning into. None of that excuses striking a person in a marked crossing. It explains why high-visibility clothing and a hand-held stop sign, which is roughly the most conspicuous a pedestrian can possibly be, still are not always enough.

The Duties Florida Imposes

Florida Statute 316.130 governs pedestrian right of way and requires drivers to yield in defined circumstances, and Florida Statute 316.1895 sets the reduced speed limits that apply in school zones during posted hours. Florida Statute 316.75 addresses who may serve as a school crossing guard and the training required. In a case like this the operative questions are ordinary ones: what the driver could and should have seen, whether the guard was where she was entitled to be, what the speed was, and whether anything obstructed the sightline. Fault is determined by an investigation, and nothing here should be read as a conclusion about the driver involved.

Two Claims Running at the Same Time

This is where a crossing guard's situation differs sharply from that of an ordinary pedestrian, and where families lose money by assuming one process covers everything.

Workers' Compensation, Against the Employer

School crossing guards in Florida are typically employed by a municipal police department, a sheriff's office, or a school district, and sometimes by a contractor. A guard struck while on duty is injured in the course and scope of employment, which means workers' compensation applies. That system pays medical treatment and a portion of lost wages without any need to prove fault, and it starts paying relatively quickly. It is also, as against the employer, generally the exclusive remedy. What it does not pay is anything for pain, suffering, disfigurement, or loss of the capacity to enjoy life.

The Liability Claim, Against the Driver

Workers' compensation does not touch the at-fault driver. A separate third-party claim can be brought against whoever caused the collision, and that claim does reach the categories workers' compensation ignores, including non-economic damages. For a 76-year-old with a brain bleed, spinal fractures, and a months-long recovery, that second claim is where the substantial value sits. Bringing it is not disloyal to an employer and does not jeopardize the compensation claim. They are designed to coexist.

The Lien That Ties Them Together

Under Florida Statute 440.39, the workers' compensation carrier that paid benefits has a right of subrogation against a recovery from the third party, meaning it can be repaid out of the settlement or verdict. Florida law provides for equitable distribution, so the amount repaid is not automatically the full sum the carrier paid, and it is frequently reduced to account for comparative fault and the limits of available insurance. How and when that lien is addressed materially changes what an injured worker actually keeps, and it is negotiated rather than simply calculated. Resolving the liability claim without addressing the lien first is one of the more expensive mistakes available in this area.

Florida's Insurance Minimums Are the Quiet Problem

The strength of a liability claim is only as useful as the insurance standing behind it, and Florida's requirements are among the thinnest in the country.

Florida Does Not Require Bodily Injury Coverage

A Florida driver must carry $10,000 in personal injury protection and $10,000 in property damage liability. Bodily injury liability coverage, the coverage that actually pays for hurting someone, is not required of most private passenger drivers. A perfectly lawful, fully insured Florida motorist can therefore strike a pedestrian and carry no coverage at all for that person's injuries. Against a hospitalization involving neurosurgery and spinal fractures, a policy carrying no bodily injury limits is functionally no policy.

Where Other Coverage Can Come From

When the at-fault driver's coverage is inadequate, the search moves elsewhere, and the answers are rarely obvious.
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on the injured person's own auto policy
  • UM coverage on a resident relative's policy in the same household
  • An employer's fleet or business auto policy, which can extend to employees injured in the course of work
  • Any umbrella or excess policy held by the at-fault driver
  • A commercial policy where the striking vehicle was being used for work at the time
Identifying every applicable policy is investigative work that has to happen early, because coverage questions shape whether a claim is worth developing at all.

The Legislature Already Flagged This Risk

School zone safety and crossing guard staffing are not obscure concerns in Florida. The state addressed both in the same piece of legislation three years ago.

HB 657 and School Zone Enforcement

Effective July 1, 2023, House Bill 657 authorized counties and municipalities to enforce school zone speed limits using speed detection systems, set specifications and public notice requirements, made the resulting photographic and video evidence admissible, and provided that violations carry no license points and cannot be used to set insurance rates. The same bill required a law enforcement agency administering such a system to run a School Crossing Guard Recruitment and Retention Program. That pairing is telling. The Legislature treated automated speed enforcement and the shortage of crossing guards as two halves of one problem, which is a reasonable read of what happens at school intersections in the morning.

The Broader Numbers

Florida records several thousand pedestrian crashes every year, and pedestrians make up a disproportionate share of the state's traffic deaths relative to their share of road users. The Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles publishes the counts in its annual Traffic Crash Facts report, and the trend has not been improving in the way anyone would want.

What Matters in the First Weeks

In a case like this the evidence is unusually good, and unusually perishable. An intersection outside an elementary school at drop-off time has more potential witnesses than almost any other location in a community.

Worth securing quickly:
  • Video from the school, nearby homes and businesses, doorbell cameras, and any bus or vehicle dash cameras
  • Contact information for parents and staff who were present, before the crowd disperses and memories blur
  • The vehicle itself, before repair, including any event data recorder download
  • Sun angle, sightline, and signage conditions at the same time of day
  • The complete traffic homicide or crash investigation file once available
  • Confirmation of every insurance policy that could respond, not just the driver's

Questions About On-Duty Pedestrian Injuries in Florida

These come up whenever someone is hurt while working on or beside a roadway.

If workers' comp is paying, why bring a second claim?

Because workers' compensation pays medical care and a fraction of lost wages and nothing else. It does not compensate pain, suffering, permanent impairment, disfigurement, or the loss of the ability to do what a person used to do. In a serious injury those categories usually exceed everything workers' compensation will ever pay, and they are only available through the claim against the at-fault party.

Will pursuing the driver hurt my workers' comp benefits?

No. The two claims are separate and are meant to run in parallel. What does need managing is the carrier's subrogation interest under Florida Statute 440.39, since it has a right to be repaid from a third-party recovery. That is a negotiation to handle deliberately rather than a reason to forgo the claim.

The driver stayed and was not charged. Does that end it?

No. A charging decision is a criminal question decided on a criminal standard, and the absence of a citation does not resolve civil liability, which turns on ordinary negligence. Many serious civil claims arise from crashes where no one was ever charged. Conversely, a citation is helpful evidence but does not by itself establish a civil case.

What if the driver has almost no insurance?

That is a common and solvable problem, and it is the reason coverage investigation happens first rather than last. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy or a household relative's policy, an employer's auto policy, and any umbrella coverage all become relevant. Whether UM coverage exists and how much is available is often the single biggest factor in the outcome of a pedestrian case.

How long is there to act?

Negligence claims accruing after March 24, 2023 generally carry a two-year limitations period in Florida, and workers' compensation has its own separate and much shorter notice requirements measured in days rather than years. Where a government entity is a defendant, additional presuit notice obligations apply. Because those clocks run independently, one being satisfied says nothing about the others.

Two Systems, One Injury

A person struck while working in a roadway sits at the intersection of two bodies of Florida law that were written separately and do not coordinate themselves. Left alone, the workers' compensation claim proceeds, the liability claim quietly expires, and the lien is settled on terms nobody negotiated.

If you or someone in your family was hurt on duty near a roadway in Florida:
  • Report the injury to the employer immediately and in writing
  • Get the crash report and the investigating agency's case number
  • Do not give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver's insurer
  • Ask what uninsured motorist coverage exists on every policy in the household
  • Have the workers' compensation lien addressed before any liability settlement
  • Preserve video and witness contacts within days, not weeks

Sources and Further Reading

If Someone in Your Family Was Hurt Working Near Traffic

Crossing guards, road crews, tow operators, utility workers, and delivery drivers all share the same exposure and the same two-track legal situation, and the coordination between those tracks is where value is won or lost. If you or a family member was struck while working on or beside a Florida roadway, having both claims looked at together costs nothing and tends to change the sequencing of everything that follows. Florida Coastal Accident and Injury Lawyers (Florida CAIL) handles Florida pedestrian and on-the-job injury claims and coordinates third-party liability claims with existing workers' compensation matters. Consultations are free and confidential, and there is no fee unless we recover compensation for you. Call 1-866-414-1111, email Team@FloridaCAIL.com, or visit our office at 801 International Parkway, 5th Floor, Lake Mary, FL 32746. This article is general information about Florida law as of its publication date and is not legal advice about any specific situation. It describes a publicly reported incident in which this firm has no involvement, and nothing here is a statement about the fault of anyone involved in it.

Explore Blog Posts

Stay ahead in the legal world with our regular updates and expert analysis on current legal developments.

blog-1
Car Accidents

Emotional Distress After a Florida Crash Must Clear Two Separate Rules

Florida stacks two independent barriers in front of a psychological injury claim: the no-fault permanent injury threshold and a common law impact rule older than the statute. Satisfying one does nothing to satisfy the other, and most coverage of this topic mentions only one...

August 10, 2026
By Scott Edgett, Trial Attorney
Read More
blog-1
Brain Injury Claims

Birth Injury Costs in Florida Are Measured in Decades, Not Bills

The CDC put the average lifetime cost of cerebral palsy near $921,000, and that figure is in 2003 dollars and describes a moderate case. Florida families also face a second question the hospital bill never raises, which is whether NICA has already replaced the claim...

August 07, 2026
By Scott Edgett, Trial Attorney
Read More
blog-1
Wrongful Death

Wrongful Death Documentation in Florida Starts With One Court Order

Florida does not let a grieving spouse, parent, or child file a wrongful death suit directly. Until a probate judge appoints a personal representative, nobody in the family has the authority to demand the medical records, crash data, or employment files the claim is built on...

August 05, 2026
By Scott Edgett, Trial Attorney
Read More
View All Blog Posts
5.0 ★Average Rating
100+Client Reviews
24+Years Experience
24/7Available Anytime

Client Stories

Why Clients Trust Florida CAIL

Real stories from injury victims across Florida who trusted us during some of the most difficult moments of their lives.

Get Legal Help

I want to share my experience with Scott Edgett and his team, because finding an attorney who truly stands with you is not something you come across often.What impressed me most was the way Scott took the time to understand me as a whole person. He did not treat my situation like something routine or transactional. He took time to learn what I valu...

C

Camille S.

Truck Accident Client

Exceptional from start to finish. Scott and his whole team were patient, prepared, communicated clearly throughout the process, and delivered a result that exceeded our expectations. You can tell they genuinely care about their clients. I couldn't recommend them more highly.

J

Jack T.

Car Accident Client

Scott and his team of lawyers are truly outstanding. They were always available during difficult times, answering our calls at virtually any hour of the day or night. Their dedication and diligence in handling our family case went above and beyond, working tirelessly to ensure complete client satisfaction. I cannot fully express my gratitude in wor...

A

Andrei H.

Wrongful Death Client

A coworker used Mr. Edgett services and a situation came up that she need answers asap. I was very impressed on how he kept responding back to her multiple times until this issue was resolved. To me it shows he's compassionate and understood what was needed and he was able to assist her.

A

AL F.

Slip and Fall Client

This law firm helped me get through a lot and I will forever be grateful to them! I always refer friends and family. Tonya was very helpful! They truly care for their clients. 10/10

G

Gabriel F.

Motorcycle Accident Client

Mallory was super helpful through a very tough process regarding my family. Amy was also very sweet and professional. Although we did not actually end up needing to hire them, they really helped us understand everything we were going through and gave us great advice! I’d definitely recommend this law firm to my friends and family.

R

Rochelle B.

Catastrophic Injury Client

I highly recommend attorney Scott Edgett law firm to any parent or family member seeking legal representation. They treated us like family and genuinely cared about our well being and daughters best interests throughout the entire process

S

Sergio g.

Catastrophic Injury Client

I trust this law firm so much! Their services are great!! Scott is AMAZING! The most professional and honest place I’ve been to. I would recommend to everyone!

M

Marlene F.

Catastrophic Injury Client

I want to share my experience with Scott Edgett and his team, because finding an attorney who truly stands with you is not something you come across often.What impressed me most was the way Scott took the time to understand me as a whole person. He did not treat my situation like something routine or transactional. He took time to learn what I valu...

C

Camille S.

Truck Accident Client

Exceptional from start to finish. Scott and his whole team were patient, prepared, communicated clearly throughout the process, and delivered a result that exceeded our expectations. You can tell they genuinely care about their clients. I couldn't recommend them more highly.

J

Jack T.

Car Accident Client

Scott and his team of lawyers are truly outstanding. They were always available during difficult times, answering our calls at virtually any hour of the day or night. Their dedication and diligence in handling our family case went above and beyond, working tirelessly to ensure complete client satisfaction. I cannot fully express my gratitude in wor...

A

Andrei H.

Wrongful Death Client

A coworker used Mr. Edgett services and a situation came up that she need answers asap. I was very impressed on how he kept responding back to her multiple times until this issue was resolved. To me it shows he's compassionate and understood what was needed and he was able to assist her.

A

AL F.

Slip and Fall Client

This law firm helped me get through a lot and I will forever be grateful to them! I always refer friends and family. Tonya was very helpful! They truly care for their clients. 10/10

G

Gabriel F.

Motorcycle Accident Client

Mallory was super helpful through a very tough process regarding my family. Amy was also very sweet and professional. Although we did not actually end up needing to hire them, they really helped us understand everything we were going through and gave us great advice! I’d definitely recommend this law firm to my friends and family.

R

Rochelle B.

Catastrophic Injury Client

I highly recommend attorney Scott Edgett law firm to any parent or family member seeking legal representation. They treated us like family and genuinely cared about our well being and daughters best interests throughout the entire process

S

Sergio g.

Catastrophic Injury Client

I trust this law firm so much! Their services are great!! Scott is AMAZING! The most professional and honest place I’ve been to. I would recommend to everyone!

M

Marlene F.

Catastrophic Injury Client

Injured? Talk To Our Team Today — Free Consultation
Free Consultation
No Fee Unless We Win
Available 24/7
Trial Attorneys

Injured In An Accident?

You Focus On Recovery. We'll Handle The Rest.

✆ 1-866-414-1111Free Consultation
main_app_logo

Fighting For Florida Injury Victims With Compassion, Experience, And Results.

Florida CAIL on FacebookFlorida CAIL on InstagramFlorida CAIL on TikTokFlorida CAIL on YouTubeFlorida CAIL on X

Phone

1-866-414-1111

Email

Team@FloridaCAIL.com

Address

801 International Pkwy, 5th Floor, Lake Mary, FL 32746
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy

© 2026 Florida CAIL · Coastal Accident & Injury Law · All rights reserved.

Powered by AG InfoTech

Injured? We're available 24/7

1-866-414-1111

Call Now